Today I welcome Michael Smith to the first draft hot seat.
Michael lives and works in Nottinghamshire. He moved there from the south of England in 1987 to do a post-graduate teaching qualification. After 3 years in local schools he re-trained as a solicitor and has worked in the Nottingham legal community ever since. He is married with two sons, and is currently summoning the resolve to start work in earnest on a second novel.
His first novel, The Deed Room, was published by independent Nottingham publisher Weathervane Press in the same month as his fiftieth birthday. This was also ten years after he completed the book, a fast-paced thriller set in Nottingham. It involves the framing of an innocent man for something awful, fraud, deception, murder and romance.
When you decide to write something new, what is the first thing you do?
I have to mull it over for some time, get the shape of it clear enough in my mind for me to be confident I can make a proper start. This doesn’t mean I will have everything mapped out in detail – far from it – but I do have to have more than a simple idea. I’ve started a couple of things when I’d not done enough thinking in advance and they quickly went nowhere.
Do you have a set routine approaching it?
No routines, but plenty of obsession. Like many writers, I have only very limited time to sit down and write, but you can make progress away from the keyboard, particularly on plots and character. When I was writing The Deed Room the book was always on my mind, and ideas about how to get to a certain point, or the ways in which somebody might behave, would come to me at all sorts of odd times during the day.
As far as actual writing is concerned, I just try to find whatever time I can. Getting up early and doing an hour before going to work was often time well spent on the novel.
Pen and paper or straight to the keyboard?
Pen and paper for notes and jottings. Straight to keyboard for anything remotely like a first draft.
How important is research to you?
I try to keep research to a minimum, partly to save time and partly because following the “write about what you know” maxim has worked well for me. The legal world I work in seems to hold a degree of interest for people, and to date has given me enough source material.
How do you go about researching?
Google for most things. Although The Deed Room is centred on Nottingham, there are scenes in London, Dublin, Rome and the South of France. For the last two I had to flesh out some detail from basic Internet searching.
I do read round subjects where necessary. I’m very interested in the notion of narcissism, and want to feature it in my next novel. So I’ve got hold of two or three books on the subject, specifically about how narcissists behave in relationships.
How do you store everything; ideas, research, images that catch your eye?
It’s a bit haphazard. I find the weekend papers a really good source of ideas and often keep articles. I also tag and bookmark things I come across online. But more recently I’ve been keeping notebooks – I find that writing notes makes me think about things a little bit more and it’s good to have everything in one place.
Tell us how that first draft takes shape?
Very, very slowly. Or at least that was the case for The Deed Room. One of the most consistent comments I’ve had from readers is about the book’s page-turning, easy-to-read qualities. If only they knew how hard it was to make it seem so easy. It reminds me of the Dolly Parton line: “It takes a whole lot of money to look this cheap.”
I’m tempted to try the approach of thrashing something out and seeing where it leads with the next book. But I’m not sure this will work. With The Deed Room, I found I had to be reasonably happy with the progress I’d made up to a certain point before moving on, and also clear about what was going to happen next. The notes in the picture show the very logical (remember, I am a lawyer) approach I took to elements of the plotting. What’s interesting to me looking back at those notes is that they came after I’d produced one draft, and that several of the ideas and scenes I’ve described in the notes still didn’t make it to the final version. The overall structure of the plot thread remained the same, but the detail changed a lot. Like I said, it’s a very slow process.
I also originally wrote the book in five distinct parts. The first thing my publisher said was to remove that structure. This was very good advice for the final work, but I found that having interim points to write towards very helpful during the process of creation.
Are there any rituals you have to do or items you must have with you while writing that draft?
No – that’s not really me.
Does the outside world exist or are you lost to us for a period of time as the magic works?
I don’t need to lock myself away. I find I can normally write with a lot going on around me. I need more quiet when editing. I try to concentrate hard on how things will come across to the reader, and I often read out loud to help with this. At this stage of the process, thirty minutes of intense concentration can be as productive as hours of distracted effort.
What does your work space look like?
It can be anywhere. I don’t like to be fixed to one place. I might use the study, but am equally happy working at the dining table, or with laptop on lap.
Edit as you go or just keep getting words out?
Definitely edit as I go – see above.
I see many writers counting words in a day. Word counter or other method of keeping track of progression?
The only goal I set myself with the first novel was to try to move the book forward each day, even if only by a tiny amount. Just writing a sentence or two or reviewing a couple of pages might be enough – the important thing was to keep the momentum going.
So, that first draft is down. Roughly how long did it take? And what shape is it in?
Somewhere between one and two years. It will be in reasonable shape – characters and plot pretty well developed – but it will still need a massive amount of revision and editing to get it to its final state. There was a ten year gap between finishing The Deed Room and finally having it published, and although it lay untouched for years I was pretty sure it was in good shape when I submitted it. I ended up removing nearly ten thousand words after that point.
In what format do you like to read it through, ereader, paper or the computer screen?
I do a lot of editing on the screen, but I also print sections and work from the page. I’ve always found – both in my legal work and when writing fiction – that I often see things straightaway on the printed page which have kept themselves very well hidden on the screen.
What happens now that first draft is done?
Edit, re-write, edit, review, edit, edit, edit. I know many writers like to put a draft to one side for a while before starting to edit, and I can see the sense in that. However, when you write as slowly as I do, there just isn’t the time.
Thanks for digging into the depths of the first draft. It’s been a pleasure having you.
You’re very welcome. It’s been fascinating revisiting the process after all this time. I even found myself up in the loft (“a place of dust and shadows” just the like the deed room itself) rooting through boxes of old drafts.
There is more information about Michael and The Deed Room on his website.
The Deed Room is available from Amazon or from Weathervane Press
To read any of the previous First Draft Q&A’s you can check the list Here.
To be a part of the First Draft series, just get in touch and let me know. Along with the answers to the questions, I’ll need a profile photograph, a first draft photograph and three links that you feel are your most important. Please don’t think I’m fully booked up, if you’re thinking about it – Get in touch!




Rebecca – Thanks for hosting Michael.
Michael – Thanks for sharing how your work takes shape. Like you, I like to let an idea evolve before I start writing. I wish I could work with things going on around me; I envy your ability to focus. I wish you much success.
Thanks, Margot. The ability to work with things going on around me is probably born of necessity – if I insisted on quiet I would never get anything done.
It is hard to make it look easy!
You’re right, Alex. But only those who’ve tried really know that!
It’s good to hear of another writer who doesn’t research too much, and who writes as slowly as me. I was starting to think I was a very small minority :-)
It’s a good minority to be in. Effort spent avoiding lots of research is effort well spent, I think, and it must be right that your writing will be more authentic if it’s about things you know well. Looking at your website, I very much envy your Cornwall location (although I imagine this winter has had its challenges).
Thanks for letting us in on your process. Hearing your comments on keeping momentum going encouraged me!
I’m glad that you’ve found it encouraging, Nancy. I like the “easy reading is damned hard writing” comment on your website.
I’m jealous that you can write what you know. ‘Tech teacher’ does not sound like the stuff of riveting novels. Law, though–that’s my sweet spot.
I don’t know. Tech teacher with only months to live uses IT knowledge to hack into bank systems intending to raise money to secure family’s future, and ends up controlling a criminal empire? In New Mexico? Or has something like that been done already?
Good to hear from you, Jacqui, and good luck with your thriller.
OK, that does sound exciting. Hmmm…